Crap. The Edmonton Oilers got booted out of the playoff picture with their loss last night to Calgary. Big downer, as it means the Oil have been out of the Stanley Cup picture both seasons that we've lived here. After 12+ years in southern Ontario, you think I'd be used to the local team not having a shot in the playoffs, but I'm still a big enough Oilers fan that this one will sting for a while.
I did wonder though how much of an impact the extra overtime loss point system played in the Oilers downfall this year -- even though they were great in the shootout, they let a lot of teams get away with that one point for making it to the overtime session. I fired up Excel and did some quick calculations for the standings, based on the old (2 pts for a W, 0 for a L) system, and a English Premier league style system (3 pts for a W, 1 for an overtime loss, and 0 for a loss). Here's the results for the Western Conference:
Classic system (2 points for a Win)
(Games, Wins, Losses, Points)
1 Detroit 79 52 27 104
2 San Jose 80 49 31 98
3* Minnesota 80 43 37 86
4 Anaheim 80 45 35 90
5 Dallas 79 43 36 86
6 Colorado 81 43 38 86
7 Calgary 80 41 39 82
8 Nashville 80 40 40 80
Edmonton 81 40 41 80
Vancouver 80 39 41 78
Chicago 79 38 41 76
Phoenix 79 37 42 74
Columbus 79 34 45 68
St. Louis 79 31 48 62
Los Angeles 80 31 49 62
* Minnesota gets 3rd place due to conference winners getting top 3 seeds.
So no help for the Oilers there, but they'd still be alive mathematically.
EPL type system (3 points for a Win, 1 point for an overtime loss)
(Games, Wins, Losses, Overtime Losses, Points)
1 Detroit 79 52 20 7 163
2 San Jose 80 49 21 10 157
3* Minnesota 80 43 28 9 138
4 Anaheim 80 45 27 8 143
5 Dallas 79 43 29 7 136
6 Colorado 81 43 31 7 136
7 Calgary 80 41 29 10 133
8 Nashville 80 40 31 9 129
Vancouver 80 39 31 10 127
Edmonton 81 40 35 6 126
Chicago 79 38 33 8 122
Phoenix 79 37 36 6 117
Columbus 79 34 33 12 114
St. Louis 79 31 35 13 106
Los Angeles 80 31 42 7 100
* Minnesota gets 3rd place due to conference winners getting top 3 seeds.
No changes in the placings here. So no help for the Oilers with this system either, but again, they'd still be alive mathematically.
Guess we just have to wait until next year...